“Book reviews: Incarcerated women and their issues - DAILY KOS” plus 2 more |
- Book reviews: Incarcerated women and their issues - DAILY KOS
- Book reviews - Egypt Today
- New and Notable book reviews - AZCentral.com
| Book reviews: Incarcerated women and their issues - DAILY KOS Posted: 07 Mar 2010 07:58 AM PST Interrupted Life: Experiences of Incarcerated Women in the United States
Readability/quality: Best taken essay by essay (or section by section) rather than read as one long volume. Since offerings range from white paper reports to passionate (and often despairing) poetry, it's hard to assess overall. First-hand accounts of conditions endured are most moving; the autobiographical details of the deplorable health care and labor standards are gruesome, infuriating and clear calls to action.
Offending Women: Power, Punishment, and the Regulation of Desire Money quote:
Author: A professor of sociology at New York University, author of Inventing the Needy: Gender and the Politics of Welfare in Hungary. Basic premise: The author looks at two programs set up in California as "community-based prisons" for mothers to be housed with their children in alternative, less institutionalized settings. One program, Alliance, was researched in the early 1990s, when the focus of social programs was moving toward insistence on self-reliance instead of the "welfare state." With this cultural imperative in the background, the program focused on emphasizing job and life skills acquisition in a boot camp-like setting (punctuality, chores, classes were all emphasized). In the second program examined a decade later, Visions, the author notes the shifting of cultural priorities--instead of prepping individuals for the basics of taking responsibility for themselves practically in society, now young mothers are coached in a brand of therapeutic self-governance, heavily reliant on 12-step methods and confessional mode. In both cases, society-wide injustices are swept under the rug; solutions are located in the individual alone, in the case of Alliance as a lack of job/life skills, in Visions as a pathologized internal child. The author examines the daily routines of both programs, their effects on the women and the growing hybrid of public/private institutions that make regulation and benchmarking difficult. Readability/quality: Relatively free of jargon, engaging when exploring the daily routines of these young mothers in each setting, thoughtful about the implications for wider society, the book is a relatively smooth read from an assured expert who clearly has spent a career looking at the issues tackled. Who should read it: Same as for Interrupted Life (in fact, one of the essays in the previous book is by this author, short and focused on only one aspect of one of these programs)--those interested in women and society, incarceration, alternative programs, children's issues. Bonus quote:
Both Alliance (skills-based) and Visions (therapeutics on steroids) sound like a nightmare. Alliance, presented first in the book, has an understandable rigidity given that these women were convicted of something (mostly drug crimes), but Haney points to the inherent contradiction in the program--even as counselors and staff are harping non-stop on self-reliance to these women, they are confiscating their AFDC aid and pooling it for survival. The women, once they get a few skills under their belts, recognize this and being reporting conditions to public agencies, spurring investigations. From a sociological point of view, Haney was in the right place at the right time to document the formation of blocs of resistance, but alas, they come to naught for various (predictable) reasons. As bad as Alliance comes across, Visions is much worse--the constant pressure to confess confess confess and to have more horror traumatic abuse stories than your fellow prisoners is appalling; women turn on each other viciously, using information gleaned in group self-help sessions, and the whole program comes across as a Jerry Springer-like emotional "Lord of the Flies." Ironically, both programs were conceived with the best of intentions: to allow women to serve time with their children, in a softer setting than normal, in a place of emotional safety and practical learning. Both programs were supported by staunch women's advocates. And both ended up mired in truly appalling dynamics. The bottom-line problem with both is the diminishment of the role of connection and empowerment; problems are always and forever seen as individual crosses to bear and hurdles to overcome. Haney's book is also a warning about the blurred area of unaccountability created by these public/private entities. Not the subject of the book, but one that would be a welcome follow-up by some author: the effect on the children of growing up in these programs. Five Filters featured article: Chilcot Inquiry. Available tools: PDF Newspaper, Full Text RSS, Term Extraction. | |
| Posted: 06 Mar 2010 09:06 PM PST Five Filters featured article: Chilcot Inquiry. Available tools: PDF Newspaper, Full Text RSS, Term Extraction. | |
| New and Notable book reviews - AZCentral.com Posted: 28 Feb 2010 03:27 AM PST 'Tooth and Claw' Nigel McCrery (Pantheon, $25.95) "The crunch of gristle and flesh separating made Lapslie's mouth tingle with sparkling wine - not Champagne but something sweeter, like Asti Spumante." That's a strange sentence, don't you think? It rings false, even though we know that, by the time we read it, Detective Mark Lapslie has a neurological disorder that translates sounds into tastes. In this case, he is watching the autopsy of a brutally murdered woman while experiencing a mental cocktail hour. Days later, a bomb explodes in a train station and a man dies. The two cases seem to have nothing in common, but through his disorder, Lapslie manages to link them. It proves that he's facing the unthinkable: a serial killer who never repeats himself, a villain whose signature is that he has no signature. The first half of the novel pulls you in, but near the end, the killer unleashes his inner fool and, in the grossest and most outlandish way, kills his father with a garden hose. It's all downhill from there, and no amount of Asti Spumante will make it better.
Ellen Fitzpatrick (Ecco, $26.99) I was weepy by the time I finished the first page of Fitzpatrick's introduction. Then I read it to my husband, and he was weepy, too. After her husband's death, Jacqueline Kennedy received more than a million condolence letters from people of all races, ages, political affiliations and economic circumstances. Saved and sorted by her staff, they have been stored in the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library. Now Fitzpatrick has assembled this poignant collection. Many of its letters reflect the same heartfelt sorrow, but some stand out. "I am just an old Mountain woman that has lived on a farm all her life," begins one. Another, from a Peace Corps volunteer in Ethiopia, called Kennedy "the reason for our being here - his idealism, his courage." And from a Georgia penitentiary came eloquence: "The lights of the prison have gone out now. In this, the quiet time, I can't help but feel that my thoughts and the thoughts of my countrymen will ever reach out to that light on an Arlington hillside for sustenance. How far that little light throws his beam."
Charles Pellegrino (Holt, $27.50) This was released in January to good reviews in everything from People to the New York Times, which called it "sober and authoritative." It's sober perhaps but not so authoritative. Pellegrino, author of several other books ("Avatar" director James Cameron reportedly is set to make a movie of this one), was conned by one of his sources. Joseph Fuoco claimed that he was a flight engineer on one of two escort planes that flew with the Enola Gay as it dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. Fuoco, who died two years ago at 84, wasn't really on the plane but gave Pellegrino detailed "recollections" of what he claimed he witnessed that day. "He found it difficult to believe what his eyes were revealing: that solid buildings could become fluid and behave like crashing waterfalls," Pellegrino writes. "Fifty-six years later . . . the image would come back to haunt him." Pellegrino promises to amend the Fuoco sections for new editions. It's an unfortunate blight on a book that contains far more than the lies of an old man.
Louise Erdrich (Harper, $14.99) "Nothing in this book is true of anyone alive or dead," says a note that appears in small type on the copyright page of this luminous collection of stories, now new in paperback. The disclaimer is charmingly simple but seems unnecessary. Erdrich's fiction has always been fierce and magical, adequately anchored in real life but always with one foot planted firmly in some other world. She has become a wiser and wittier writer over the years, or perhaps it's only that we've acquired the wisdom to recognize in her novels the richness that has always been there. The 36 stories here were written over three decades. If you've read her best work - "Love Medicine," "The Last Report on the Miracles at Little No Horse," "The Plague of Doves" and others - you will recognize some of the territory (North Dakota and the Ojibwe Indian Reservation) and many of the names (Nanapush, Adare, Kashpaw, Damien, DeWitt). If you're new to her fiction, you'll have the pleasure of discovering stories that are humane and mysteriously alive. Five Filters featured article: Chilcot Inquiry. Available tools: PDF Newspaper, Full Text RSS, Term Extraction. |
| You are subscribed to email updates from Book-Reviews - Bing News To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
| Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610 | |

0 comments:
Post a Comment